BioModels Workshop 2009: Day 2

Today was great fun – lots of presentations and lots of lively discussions, of which we were all a part, but which Nicolas Le Novère ("shown" left, courtesy of Falko Krause 🙂 ) also enjoyed.

Here are the notes!

CellML: Catherine Lloyd

Most of the talk aligned with the talk Catherine gave at BioSysBio 2009 this past week. Some parts were new, however. For instance, she seemed to spend a little more time on versioning. A version is an update of a model entry – usually with a traceable model history. A variant is a slightly different model from the same reference. A variant could be the same model adapted for adifferent cell type. Alternatively, variants of a model may be created to reproduce the different figures from a publication.

libAnnotationSBML: Neil Swainston

Automatic Linking of MIRIAM Annotation to a model using web services. He was involved with the creation of the SBML metabolic yeast network, which had MIRIAM annotations. And now that this qualitative information has been published, they're doing some experiments to get quantitative data. They developed a simple CellDesigner plugin as proof-of-concept to allow the linking of a model to their quantitative data repository (not finished yet).

MIRIAM annotations are a form of tagging the model. However, they want to do more: use the annotations to "reason" over the model. By "reason", they mean doing more than just seeing if the model is annotated: but seeing if the model is being annotated well. Do the reactions balance? Such a question cannot solely be answered by libSBML, and they can use ChEBI to do this. As a human, you would go to the ChEBI entry and get the formula from ChEBI. Then, you can compare that to your reaction. Can this be done automatically?

libAnnotationSBML connects to ChEBI, KEGG, UniProt, MIRIAM. This information is presented in a single convenience class. This stuff has a "SBML Reaction Balance Analyser". They don't do any automatic corrections, but they can identify where something doesn't match with ChEBI. Would like to do it automatically in the near future. Would also like to suggest corrections to existing models (incorrect annotations, missing reactants / products, stoichiometry). Would like to intelligently generate models.

Future: support more web services, write it in C++, or perhaps ask the MIRIAM people to have a web service method that retrieves the URL for the wsdl as well as the human-readable URL. However, connections to web services tend to be inconsistent, and therefore you can't always get the information you want.

semanticSBML: Falko Krause

You can find more information here: Here there is a standalone GUI which is capable of offline annotation. There is also a web interface.

This is in fact a much more interesting application than is suggested by the notes – mainly I was preoccupied with making sure my talk was ready to go, as it was almost my turn. I highly recommend that you have a look at the link above and have a play with this software.


I didn't speak directly about Saint, as I will be speaking about MFO instead this afternoon. However, as model annotation was being talked about today, I thought it might be useful for me to put up some information about Saint. The presentation and video will be up on the IET website (but isn't yet). In the meantime, here's a rundown of the purpose of Saint.

The creation of accurate quantitative Systems Biology Markup Language (SBML) models is a time-intensive manual process. Modellers need to know and understand both the systems they are modelling and the intricacies of SBML. However, the amount of relevant data for even a relatively small and well-scoped model is overwhelming. Saint, an automated SBML annotation integration environment, aims to aid the modeller and reduce development time by providing extra information about any given SBML model in an easy-to-use interface. Saint accepts SBML-formatted files and integrates information from multiple databases automatically. Any new information that the user agrees with is then automatically added to the SBML model.

The initial functionality of Saint allows the annotation of already-extant species and suggests additional interactions. The user uploads their SBML model, and the portions of the model recognized by Saint are then displayed using a tabular structure. The user can then remove any items they are not interested in annotating. For instance, some terms such as "sink" are modelling artefacts and do not correspond to genes or proteins. Therefore, the user would normally wish to delete this from the search space to prevent any possible matches with actual biological species of a similar name. Once the user is satisfied with the list of items to be annotated, the model is submitted using the "Annotate Listed Items" button at the bottom of the table. A summary of the annotation returned by Saint is then added to the main table. The user can then remove any new annotation that is unsuitable for their model. At any stage, the user may click on the "Annotated Model" tab in Saint, which adds all new annotation to the original model and presents the new SBML model for viewing and download.

While there are a number of tools available for manipulating and validating SBML (e.g. LibSBML), simulating SBML models (e.g. BASIS and the SBML Toolbox ), and analysing simulations (e.g. COPASI,), and running modelling workflows (e.g. Taverna ), Saint is the first to provide basic automatic annotation of SBML models in an easy-to-use GUI. The purpose of Saint is to aid the researcher in the difficult task of information discovery by seamlessly querying multiple databases and providing the results of that query within the SBML model itself. By providing a modelling interface to existing data integration resources and, modellers are able to add valuable information to models quickly and simply.

Saint already generates reactions and associated new species and species references. It is being extended this creation of reactions to also generate skeleton models based around a species or pathway of interest.

SBO: Nick Juty

The sourceforge website has a tracker as well as access to the whole project. You can browse the whole tree from Your search retrieves a series of tables, and they will retrieve obsolete terms so that you can tell what used to be there. The main curation works happens via a web interface that directly talks to the database (this is just for curation). Lots of web services available.

From SBML to SBGN through SBO: Alice Villeger

Semantic annotations as a bridge between standards. Showed a very nice modification to the SBGN reference card where she colored sections by their SBO branch, which then showed up areas where different branches were used for the same type of notation (and therefore were candidates for modification within SBO). She showed that the SBML info needed is in Species Reference => this can be solved by changing the current SBGN specs. Further, there are some SBO terms that have no direct SBML equivalent (e.g. or, and). She gave a number of other examples, too.

It also seems that the compartment in SBGN and the SBML specification don't match. This is because the SBML compartment is not intended to be the same as the SBGN compartment (a functional versus a physical compartment).

Her analysis of the alignment of SBGN and SBO showed up a number of inconsistencies. This was really useful. There should be some machine-readable expression of SBML x SBO and SBGN x SBO. Further, there aren't many models annotated with
SBO yet. And, if they are, they are not always sufficiently precise. One solution could be a MIRIAM to SBO converter program.

Please note that this post is merely my notes on the presentation. They are not guaranteed to be correct, and unless explicitly stated are not my opinions. They do not reflect the opinions of my employers. Any errors you can happily assume to be mine and no-one else's. I'm happy to correct any errors you may spot – just let me know!

Read and post comments |
Send to a friend



1 thought on “BioModels Workshop 2009: Day 2”

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s